10 Best Cat Litter for Multiple Cats: Choosing the Right Option

Last Updated: 10 months ago

Are you looking for the best cat litter for multiple cats?

Picking up the right brand can make a difference in keeping multi-cat households clean, so it’s natural to want the best. 

Fortunately, I’m here to review the best 10 cat litter for multiple cats and narrow down your options.

Just keep reading.  

Best Multi Cat Litter at a Glance

• Winner: Dr. Elsey Ultra Premium Clumping Litter
• Best Low Dust: Arm & Hammer Clump & Seal Platinum Cat Litter
• Best for Odor Control: Fresh Step Advanced Multi Cat
• Best Natural: World’s Best Cat Litter 
• Best Low-Tracking: BoxieCat Litter

10 Best Cat Litter For Multi Cats

It’s a joy to have multiple kitties running around the house and keeping you on your toes all day long.

But cleaning multiple litter boxes can be a challenge, especially if the litter keeps sticking to the box.

Fortunately, the solution to your problem is a simple one – switch to a cat litter brand suitable for multiple cats!

But what is the best cat litter for multiple cats? Let’s see my top suggestions. 

#1 Winner: Dr. Elsey Ultra Premium Clumping Litter

Dr. Elsey is one of the most popular cat litter brands for good reasons.

It has excellent clumping power, natural ingredients, and superior odor control, making it the best kitty litter for multiple cats. 

Features & Attributes

Dr. Elsey’s premium clumping litter has finely textured granules with no added fragrances or chemicals. The formula is hypoallergenic and 99% dust-free. 

Measurements

• Available in a bag of 40 pounds
• Ultra Scented Litter is available 

Benefits

• Dr. Elsey’s products form hard clumps on contact with cat urine, so it’s easy to scoop the solid clumps without breaking them apart. 
• Excellent granule texture for kitties with sensitive paws
• 100% bentonite clay with no added chemicals or additives
• Great for automatic cat litter boxes, such as Litter-Robot 
• Low-dust, hypoallergenic formula, suitable for cats and owners with allergies.
• The medium grain granule size reduces tracking around the house and keeps the litter inside the litter box.
• Available in a scented version for outstanding odor control, suitable for cats that don’t find fragrances.

Drawbacks

• Not the cheapest options
• Heavy bag

How it Compares to Others

Dr. Elsey’s quick-action formula has better clumping power than similar brands.

There’s almost no dust when you pour the litter into the box.

How it’s evolved over time

Dr. Elsey is constantly working on improving its formula, so its product line has expanded in recent years. 

Expert Tips & Testimonials

Consider Dr. Elsey’s litter attractant if you have issues with cats peeing outside the litter box. 

9 out of 10 cat owners highly recommend Dr. Elsey and are satisfied with its absorbency, odor control, and tracking.

The litter does not smell and clumps wonderfully. The best part is for the benefit of the cat–when the cat kicks up the litter too energetically, there isn’t a dust storm!”

#2 Best Low Dust: Arm & Hammer Clump & Seal Platinum Cat Litter

Arm & Hammer’s unscented litter is perfect for multi-cat houses since it keeps unpleasant litter box odors at bay for seven days. 

Features & Attributes

Arm & Hammer’s product is made from natural clay with a patented odor-sealing, unscented formula, moisture-activated granules, and baking soda. 

Measurements

• Available in bags of 18, 27.5, and 40 pounds 

Benefits

• It forms tight clumps on contact with liquid waste, so it is easy to scoop the solid waste. 
• The formula contains baking soda and moisture-activated granules for 7-day odor control. 
• Low-dust formula, perfect for cat owners with allergies
• No scent to bother sensitive cats 
• Available in small cat litter bags

Drawbacks

• Tracks around the house
• The litter is unscented, but some cat owners report an unpleasant scent

How it Compares to Others

It’s very low dust compared to similar brands, and as you can see from this video, its clumping ability is superior to most commercial brands.

How it’s evolved over time

Improved formula for better clumping and odor control

Expert Tips & Testimonials

If you’re not satisfied with the 7-day odor control, you can ask for a refund. 

Most cat owners are impressed with Arm & Hammer’s clumping litter and highly praise its odor control and lack of dust.

As this owner shares, “I use Arm and Hammer clump and seal for multi cats. It’s expensive but no odor if the cat buries his business and No dust to breathe in.”

#3 Best for Odor Control: Fresh Step Clumping Cat Litter

Thanks to its excellent odor control, Fresh Step Advanced is one of the best litters for multiple cats.

Features & Attributes

• Unscented
• Medium-sized clay granules 

Measurements

• Available in an 18.7 or 37-pound bag

Benefits

• The 10-day odor control keeps your house free of unpleasant odors, no matter how many cats you have.
• Unique extra-strength formula to suit multi-cat homes 
• It doesn’t stick and forms hard litter clumps for quick removal and disposal.
• One of the most affordable multi-cat litters
• Febreze Freshness fragrance for extra odor control 

Drawbacks

• Small granule size, so it tracks too much for some customers
• A bit dusty

How it Compares to Others

• Better clumping formula than traditional clay litters 
• One of the best odor-controlling properties 

How it’s evolved over time

• New formula for less dust and better clumping 

Expert Tips & Testimonials

Consider Fresh Step Advanced Clean Paws if you want a low-tracking brand. 

Most pet parents are happy with Fresh Step’s clumping litter and its 10-day odor control formula.

But as this reviewer says, “It clumps just fine, but they track it all over the house.”

#4 Best Natural: World’s Best Cat Litter Multiple Cat Litter

World’s Best Litter is the best litter for multiple cats and owners who want a natural product free of clay. 

Features & Attributes

• Corn-based cat litter
• Unscented 

Measurements

• Available in a 32-pound bag 

Benefits

• Made from whole-kernel corn with no harmful ingredients, such as silica dust
• Quick clumping, so it’s suitable for automatic litter boxes 
• No artificial fragrances 
• Long-lasting odor control with natural ingredients
• Lightweight formula for easy handling 
• Flushable 

Drawbacks

• Litter tracking 
• Not all cats like it
• Not the best low-dust formula

How it Compares to Others

Unlike traditional clay clumping litter, this brand is made from corn but has similar clumping abilities.

It’s also relatively less dusty and doesn’t track as much as traditional brands. 

How it’s evolved over time

• Improved formula to handle multiple cats and keep odors under control 
• It’s available in a scented lavender version. 

Expert Tips

• Introduce this type of litter slowly to get your cat used to its texture. 

Testimonials

As this reviewer says, “I love World’s Best! It clumps well, doesn’t track, and isn’t dusty at all.”

Thanks to its super absorbent granules and eco-friendly formula, most cat owners highly recommend World’s Best Litter.

#5 Best Low-Tracking: Boxiecat Premium Clumping Clay Cat Litter

BoxieCat is one of the best clay-based litters for multiple cats, thanks to its extra-strength formula and quick clumping action. 

Features & Attributes

• Medium-sized granules 
• Scent-free
• Probiotics & natural ingredients

Measurements

• Available in bags of 18 or 28 pounds 

Benefits

• Rapid-clumping action for rock-hard clumps, making it easy to scoop cat waste from the toilet box.
• Long-lasting formula
• Minimal dust levels when you pour the litter into the box
• Extra-strong odor-controlling formula with probiotics, perfect for cats with stinky poop and multiple felines
• Suitable for all types of litter boxes 
• Soft-textured granules, suitable for cats with sensitive paws 

Drawbacks

• Not the cheapest option
• Bags are easy to rip

How it Compares to Others

• It’s more expensive than most clumping clay litter brands, but it has one of the most long-lasting formulas. 
• Boxie Cat uses probiotics for improved odor control and a clean litter box. 

How it’s evolved over time

• New bag design with handles and a pour spout for convenience

Expert Tips & Testimonials

Try BoxieCat Deep Clean if you want to keep bacteria from accumulating on the bottom of the box. 

As this cat parent explains, “I use BoxieCat, highly recommend the orange label (extra strength scent-free) stuff.” Most reviewers have similar opinions and praise BoxieCat’s texture and low-dust formula. 

#6 Best Budget-Friendly: Tidy Cats Clumping Litter

Purina Tidy Cat Max’s formula has you covered if you’re looking for the best kitty litter for multiple cats for owners on a tight budget.

Features & Attributes

• Natural Clay
• Scented 

Measurements

• Available in a bag of 38 pounds

Benefits

• Moisture-activated pieces for quick clumping and easy scooping
• Ammonia blockers to keep unpleasant litter box odors at bay for up to two weeks with regular litter box maintenance
• Extra-strong formula to manage multiple cats and neutralized urine and feces smells 
• Soft on the paws, so cats like it 
• Relatively low dust and low tracking

Drawbacks

• Heavy box with no handle
• Strong litter scent 
• Not the best choice for automatic litter boxes 

How it Compares to Others

Purina’s Tidy Max 4-in-1 absorbs moisture well, but it doesn’t have the same clumping power as the other brands I’ve reviewed. The clumps are easy to break.

How it’s evolved over time

• Improved formula for neutralizing three key litter box odors 

Expert Tips & Testimonials

Sprinkle some baking soda on the bottom of the litter box if the litter sticks. 

Cat parents like Purina Tidy Cats Max are satisfied with its absorbency and price.

Some cat owners say that it’s awesome and you can’t find anything better for multiple cats.

#7 Best Non-Clumping Cat Litter: Naturally Fresh

Naturally Fresh is among the best cat litter for multiple cats, thanks to its unique walnut-based litter formulas and lack of silica dust. 

Features & Attributes

• Walnut cat litter
• Unscented 

Measurements

• Available in a bag of 14 or  26 pounds

Benefits

• Made from all natural products with no added chemicals, fragrances, or silica dust 
• Excellent clumping power
• Excellent odor control, thanks to the natural odor-neutralizing ingredients 
• Eco-friendly and biodegradable
• Lasts longer than traditional clay cat litters

Drawbacks

• Too dusty for some customers
• Tracks around the house

How it Compares to Others

It’s eco-friendly and generates almost no dust when you pour it into the box.

And as this Reddit cat owner says,” It’s lightweight, so a 26lb bag lasts a lot longer than other 26lb bags.”

How it’s evolved over time

• Improved packaging 

Expert Tips & Testimonials

Mix one inch of the walnut shells with your usual type of litter to get your cat used to the new texture. 

A cat owner says, “I switched to Naturally Fresh walnut-based litter, and it’s been lovely ever since.

It smells like walnut and coffee.” Most customers share the same option and highly recommend it. 

#8 Best for Long-haired cats: Ökocat Less Mess

You won’t be disappointed by Okocat and its natural wood pellet cat litter if you have several long-haired cats. 

Features & Attributes

• Wood fiber pellets
• Unscented 

Measurements

• Available in a box of 14.8 or 18.6 pounds  

Benefits

• Made from natural wood fibers with no harmful additives
• Rapid clumping action to trap moisture and odors on contact 
• Easy to clean and scoop
• Less likely to stick to cat’s fur thanks to the larger particles 
• Wood fibers naturally repress unpleasant ammonia and feces smells

Drawbacks

• Expensive
• Not all cats like pellet texture

How it Compares to Others

• A bit messier than traditional clay brands 

How it’s evolved over time

• A new box design with a leak-proof bag inside 

Expert Tips & Testimonials

Check this video on how to scoop/clean cat litter pellets.

Most cat owners are happy with Okocat’s wood pellets and highly recommend it due to its low-dust and low-tracking formula.

And as this owner says, “One box lasts forever, and it’s lightweight.”

#9 Best Unscented Cat Litter: Ever Clean Extra Strength

Ever Clean is another excellent option for multi-cat owners, thanks to its superior clumping power and low-tracking formula. 

Features & Attributes

• Natural minerals and clay
• An antimicrobial agent

Measurements

• A 14-pound bag

Benefits

• Highly absorbent formula with advanced moisture lock 
• It locks in odor well, thanks to plant-based extracts and the Carbon Plus technology that eliminate the dirty litter box smells 
• Antimicrobial agents keep bacterial from accumulating inside the toilet box 
• 10-day guaranteed freshness

Drawbacks

• A bit dusty
• Expensive

How it Compares to Others

• Dustier than other clay litters I’ve reviewed
• Uses antimicrobial agents for a clean toilet box 

Expert Tips & Testimonials

Scoop the toilet box more often if the clumps stick to the bottom and walls. 

Ever Clean performs exceptionally well, forms easy-to-scoop clumps, and cats like it.

#10 Best Lightweight: Cat’s Pride Clumping Cat Litter

Cat’s Pride has an excellent lightweight litter, perfect for multiple cats and owners that don’t want to lift heavy bags. 

Features & Attributes

• Unscented clay litter 
• Hypoallergenic formula

Measurements

• Available in 10-pound containers 

Benefits

• Excellent absorbency and quick clumping action
• It doesn’t stick to the walls and the bottom of the box
• Suitable for sensitive cats and people with allergies, thanks to its hypoallergenic formula
• A 10-day odor control
• Baking soda for complete odor elimination 
• Very affordable 

Drawbacks

• Tracking issue

How it Compares to Others

It’s better at absorbing urine and controlling odors than most brands, but cats track it around the house because of the lightweight formula.

Expert Tips & Testimonials

Use a litter mat to reduce the tracking around the house. 

Cat owners have a position opinion of Cat’s Pride Clumping Litter, saying it’s awesome, dust-free, and controls odors very well. 

How To Choose The Best Multi-Cat Litter?

Since you have such a wide variety of brands to choose from, let’s talk about what features to consider when shopping for the best multi-cat litter.

#1 Texture

As vets explain, “Most cats prefer small loose granules that can be easily pushed about with their feet and that shake off easily as they exit the box.”

So, choose a brand close to your cat’s preferences to ensure your cat doesn’t start peeing outside the litter box.

#2 Dust

With multiple cats digging in the litter boxes, you should opt for a brand with minimal dust to avoid respiratory problems in cats.

#3 Tracking

It’s a nightmare when one cat tracks litter particles around the house, but it’s a catastrophe when multiple cats leave prints all over the floors.

So, the best kitty litter for multiple cats doesn’t track a lot and doesn’t stick to the cat’s paws.  

#4 Odor Control

Multiple cats mean a lot of stinky toilet boxes around the house. You need a brand to keep odors under control without changing the box every couple of days.

Or you can consider some alternatives to cat litter boxes to keep the odors at bay. 

#5 Absorbency

The most important feature to consider is how well the litter brand absorbs moister and whether it forms hard clumps for easy scooping. 

FAQs

Final Recommendation

Picking up the right kitty litter for multiple cats can make all the difference and help you keep your house clean and mess-free.

And while all these 10 best cat litters for multiple cats will do an excellent job, we highly recommend Dr. Elsey’s Ultra Clumping Litter.

It’s one of the most absorbent brands on the market, controls odors well, and is relatively dust free and low-tracking compared to other clumping litters. 

What do you think about these 10 best litters for multiple cats? Which brand is your favorite? Share your thoughts in the comment section. 

Resources:

• ShopPetPlanet.com
• PetMD.com

Last update on 2024-04-30 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API